Best American Cookies


Levain Bakery Chocolate Chip Cookie - New York, NY

New Yorkers love this crispy-inside, gooey-outside cookie. It's huge enough to share, but you won't want to. Levain Bakery has this cookie in numerous NYC locations

Milk Bar Compost Cookie - New York, NY

Milk Bar is known for its creative desserts, including the Compost Cookie. Pretzels, potato chips, coffee grounds, oats, butterscotch, and chocolate chips make this cookie crunchy and chewy. It's at Milk Bars in NYC and beyond.

Insomnia Cookies Double Chocolate Chunk Cookie - Nationwide

Insomnia Cookies' Double Chocolate Chunk Cookie is for chocolate lovers. It's chewy with dark chocolate pieces. Many US college towns and localities sell Insomnia Cookies

Bouchon Bakery TKO (Thomas Keller Oreo) - Yountville, CA

Bouchon Bakery's Oreo-inspired TKO is handmade. Two dark chocolate shortbread cookies sandwich white chocolate ganache. It's decadent and wonderful at Bouchon Bakery in Yountville, CA, and Las Vegas, NV.

Rustica Bakery Peanut Butter Cookie - Minneapolis, MN

Rustica Bakery in Minneapolis makes great peanut butter cookies. It's buttery and chewy with peanut butter cup chunks. Peanut butter lovers enjoy it.


Tiff's Treats Chocolate Chip Cookie - Austin, TX

Austin's Tiff's Treats delivers warm, fresh-baked cookies. High-quality chocolate chips and a proprietary blend of ingredients make their Chocolate Chip Cookie irresistible.

Eleni's New York Classic Sugar Cookie - New York, NY

New York City's Eleni's Traditional Sugar Cookie is as tasty as their adorned sugar cookies. It's buttery, not too sweet, and crunchy, excellent for dunking in tea or coffee.

Salty Tart Bakery Chocolate Chip Cookie - Minneapolis, MN

Salty Tart Bakery in Minneapolis provides great chocolate chip cookies. It's soft, chewy, and laden with melt-in-your-mouth chocolate chunks.

Fat Witch Bakery Blondie - New York, NY

Fat Witch Bakery in New York City specialises in brownies and blondies, and their Blondie is a must-try. Brown sugar, butter, and vanilla give it a caramelised taste. At their Chelsea Market bakery.